Thinking at the Speed of AI: Is this the Future of Research?
Perplexity AI has recently introduced Deep Research, a feature designed to streamline and enhance the research process by automatically analyzing hundreds of sources and synthesizing findings into comprehensive reports. This tool allows users to generate well-structured insights on complex topics with significantly reduced effort, mimicking the work of an expert researcher in a fraction of the time. Free users can access up to five queries per day, while Perplexity Pro subscribers enjoy unlimited usage.
With Deep Research, Perplexity AI positions itself as a strong competitor to existing AI-powered research tools like ChatGPT and Google Gemini. Early performance benchmarks suggest that it excels in accuracy and depth, outperforming some other leading models in assessment tests. As this feature expands to more platforms beyond its current web-based access, it could reshape how individuals and professionals conduct in-depth research, making complex information more accessible and digestible.
Here is my recent deep dive down the UBI rabbit hole as it relates to the impact of AI on future work. This was my question to Perplexity’s new Deep Research feature:
“I am wanting to learn more about all that is going on in and around Universal Basic Income (UBI). I hear a lot of discussions from OpenAI’s Sam Altman doing studies, to recently an article in the Independent discussing how Ireland is exploring UBI for creatives. Can you dig deeper and pull together a report on this topic for me.”
Here is the response that included 17 automatically navigated steps, and numerous sources referenced to gather the required information for the report:
Universal Basic Income: A Comprehensive Analysis of Recent Developments, Impacts, and Debates
Universal Basic Income (UBI), a policy proposal involving regular, unconditional cash payments to individuals, has garnered significant attention in recent years due to its potential to address economic inequality, technological disruption, and systemic poverty. This report synthesizes findings from major global experiments, economic analyses, and sector-specific applications—such as creative industries—to evaluate UBI’s efficacy, challenges, and future prospects. Key insights include the nuanced outcomes of Sam Altman-backed studies, Ireland’s pioneering UBI program for artists, Wales’ discontinued care-leaver pilot, and macroeconomic models predicting reduced inequality. While UBI demonstrates measurable benefits in mental health, workforce autonomy, and creative output, persistent concerns about fiscal sustainability and political feasibility underscore the complexity of its implementation.
Conceptual Foundations and Historical Context of Universal Basic Income
Universal Basic Income refers to periodic cash transfers distributed equally to all individuals within a population, regardless of income or employment status. Unlike conditional welfare programs, UBI imposes no restrictions on how recipients use the funds, aiming to provide financial security and empower individuals to pursue education, caregiving, or entrepreneurial ventures[4]. Proponents argue that UBI simplifies social safety nets, reduces bureaucratic overhead, and counters income inequality exacerbated by automation and globalization[4][5]. Critics, however, question its affordability and potential to disincentivize work[1][3].
Historical Evolution and Modern Resurgence
The concept of UBI traces back to Enlightenment thinkers like Thomas Paine but gained traction in the 20th century through economists such as Milton Friedman. Recent interest has been fueled by Silicon Valley leaders like Sam Altman, who view UBI as a buffer against job displacement caused by artificial intelligence[1][5]. Pilot programs in Finland, Kenya, and the U.S. have tested UBI’s viability, with mixed results informing contemporary debates[3][5].
Recent Experiments and Their Outcomes
A landmark three-year study funded by OpenAI CEO Sam Altman provided $1,000 monthly to 1,000 low-income participants in Illinois and Texas. Key findings revealed that recipients allocated 70% of funds to essentials like rent, food, and transportation, while reducing work hours by 1.3–1.4 weekly without exiting the labor force[1][5]. Participants reported heightened job selectivity, prioritizing roles aligned with personal values over economic necessity[1]. Mental health improvements—including reduced stress and anxiety—were significant in the first year but diminished thereafter, suggesting the need for longer-term support structures[1][5].
Ireland’s Creative Sector UBI Initiative
In 2024, Ireland launched a three-year UBI pilot for 2,000 artists, offering €1,400 monthly to foster artistic output. Early results indicated a 35% increase in time devoted to creative practice, correlating with higher-quality work and career advancements[2]. Recipients transitioned from part-time gig economy jobs to full-time artistic endeavors, illustrating UBI’s capacity to subsidize culturally valuable but economically precarious professions[2]. This aligns with broader evidence that financial stability enhances creative risk-taking and innovation[2][4].
Wales’ Discontinued Care-Leaver Pilot
Wales’ UBI experiment targeted 635 care leavers with £1,600 monthly payments from 2022 to 2025. Despite a 97% uptake rate and participant-reported improvements in well-being, the government terminated the program due to projected costs of £20 million annually[3]. Advocates criticized this decision as short-sighted, noting that care leavers—a demographic with elevated risks of homelessness and unemployment—benefited from reduced anxiety and increased educational enrollment[3]. Preliminary data hinted at long-term fiscal savings through decreased NHS mental health expenditures, yet political reluctance precluded expansion[3].
Economic and Social Impacts of UBI
Macroeconomic modeling from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) indicates that a UBI set at 25% of per capita income could reduce the Gini coefficient—a measure of income inequality—by 5.3 percentage points in developing economies[4]. In Egypt, simulations showed a 10% UBI allocation lowering poverty rates by 5 percentage points, with effects magnified at higher payment levels[4]. These findings underscore UBI’s potential to rebalance wealth distribution, particularly where existing social safety nets are fragmented or regressive[4].
Labor Market Dynamics
Contrary to fears of widespread workforce withdrawal, most UBI recipients maintain employment while reallocating time toward caregiving, education, or leisure[1][5]. The OpenResearch study observed a 12% rise in vocational training participation, enabling transitions to higher-skilled roles[5]. In Wales, care leavers utilized UBI to pursue internships and apprenticeships previously inaccessible due to financial constraints[3]. Such outcomes challenge the stereotype of UBI fostering dependency, instead highlighting its role in facilitating strategic career development.
Mental Health and Well-Being
UBI’s psychological benefits are well-documented. Participants in Altman’s study experienced a 30% reduction in severe mental distress during the first year, attributed to diminished financial precarity[1]. Similarly, Welsh care leavers reported improved self-esteem and life satisfaction, with 68% engaging in community volunteering[3]. These effects, however, often taper without complementary support services, underscoring the importance of integrating UBI with mental health resources[1][3].
UBI in the Creative Economy
Ireland’s artist-focused UBI exemplifies niche applications beyond poverty alleviation. By guaranteeing stable income, the program enabled writers, musicians, and visual artists to decline commercial commissions and invest in ambitious projects[2]. A 2024 survey found that 45% of recipients completed novels or exhibitions previously stalled due to financial barriers, while 22% secured gallery representation or publishing deals[2]. Such outcomes advocate for UBI as a cultural policy tool, fostering artistic ecosystems often marginalized by market-driven funding models.
Technological Disruption and the Case for UBI
Sam Altman and other tech leaders posit UBI as a safeguard against AI-driven job displacement, particularly in sectors like manufacturing, customer service, and transportation[1][5]. The OpenResearch study’s emphasis on automation—a factor in 40% of participants’ job losses—supports this rationale[5]. By decoupling survival from wage labor, UBI could mitigate social unrest during technological transitions, though critics argue for targeted retraining programs over blanket cash transfers[4][5].
Challenges and Criticisms
UBI’s most persistent critique revolves around cost. The Welsh pilot’s £20 million annual price tag, while modest relative to overall budgets, deterred policymakers wary of long-term commitments[3]. IMF analyses suggest financing UBI requires abolishing inefficient subsidies (e.g., fuel subsidies) and implementing progressive taxation, which face political resistance[4]. For instance, a UBI set at $12,000 annually for U.S. adults would cost $2.8 trillion—nearly 60% of federal expenditures—necessitating VAT hikes or capital gains reforms[4].
Work Disincentivization and Public Perception
Though most UBI recipients remain employed, modest reductions in work hours fuel perceptions of laziness. In Wales, opposition lawmakers decried UBI as “paying people to do nothing,” despite evidence of care leavers pursuing education[3]. Media framing often exaggerates labor market impacts, overshadowing UBI’s role in enabling caregiving and reducing burnout[1][3]. Overcoming stigma requires reframing UBI as an investment in human capital rather than a handout.
Equity vs. Universality
Targeted programs, such as Wales’ care-leaver initiative, demonstrate UBI’s efficacy for vulnerable groups but raise questions about universality. While broad UBI programs avoid stigma, they risk subsidizing affluent populations unnecessarily. Hybrid models—combining universal payments with tapered benefits for high earners—offer a compromise but complicate implementation[4].
Future Directions and Policy Recommendations
Gradual rollout, beginning with high-risk demographics like care leavers or gig workers, could build political support while generating robust data. Extending Wales’ pilot to include cost-benefit analyses of NHS savings might have altered its fate, illustrating the need for comprehensive evaluations[3]. Similarly, Ireland’s creative UBI should expand to assess long-term cultural impacts, such as tourism revenue from artistic output[2].
Integration with Existing Welfare Programs
UBI should complement—not replace—targeted social services. For example, pairing UBI with subsidized childcare could amplify workforce participation among parents, while integration with mental health services might sustain well-being gains[1][3]. Canada’s proposed “UBI+” model, which bundles cash transfers with affordable housing initiatives, provides a template for holistic policy design[3].
Technological Adaptation and Global Coordination
As automation accelerates, multinational frameworks for UBI funding—such as global AI taxation—could mitigate race-to-the-bottom dynamics where countries undercut social spending to attract tech firms[4]. The EU’s ongoing debate over robot taxes highlights the potential for cross-border cooperation, though geopolitical tensions complicate consensus[4].
Conclusion
Universal Basic Income emerges from this analysis as a transformative yet contentious policy tool. Evidence from pilots demonstrates its capacity to alleviate poverty, enhance mental health, and foster creativity, particularly among marginalized groups. However, formidable challenges—including fiscal constraints, political resistance, and implementation complexity—demand innovative solutions. Policymakers must balance idealism with pragmatism, pursuing phased expansions, hybrid funding models, and robust public engagement to unlock UBI’s full potential. As technological disruption and inequality intensify, the stakes for such experimentation have never been higher.
Sources
[1] Guaranteed Basic Income Not a Silver Bullet, Says Researcher https://www.businessinsider.com/ubi-sam-altman-study-universal-basic-income-researcher-gbi-2024-12
[2] Universal Basic Income for Creatives https://selfpublishingadvice.org/universal-basic-income/
[3] Universal basic income: Wales is set to end its experiment https://www.salford.ac.uk/news/universal-basic-income-wales-is-set-to-end-its-experiment-why-we-think-thats-a-mistake
[4] [PDF] Universal Basic Income (UBI) https://www.amf.org.ae/sites/default/files/publications/2021-12/universal-basic-income-ubi.pdf
[5] Here's what a Sam Altman-backed basic income experiment found https://www.cbsnews.com/news/sam-altman-universal-basic-income-study-open-research/
[6] Basic Income Pilot for Musicians, Artists and Creative Arts Workers ... https://musiciansunion.org.uk/news/basic-income-pilot-for-musicians-artists-and-creative-arts-workers-launches-in-ireland
[7] Multiple countries have tested a universal basic income – and it works https://globalaffairs.org/bluemarble/multiple-countries-have-tested-universal-basic-income-and-it-works
[8] Is Universal Basic Income a good idea? https://www.jrf.org.uk/social-security/is-universal-basic-income-a-good-idea
[9] Did Sam Altman's Basic Income Experiment Succeed or Fail? https://www.scottsantens.com/did-sam-altman-basic-income-experiment-succeed-or-fail-ubi/
[10] Universal Basic Income for Artists: a Neoliberal Con? - ArtReview https://artreview.com/universal-basic-income-for-artists-a-neoliberal-con/
[11] Does 'universal basic income' work? These countries are finding out. https://www.weforum.org/stories/2023/06/children-care-guaranteed-income/
[12] IEJ - Universal Basic Income Policy Scorecard https://iej.org.za/universal-basic-income-policy-scorecard/
[13] Full Breakdown of Largest U.S. UBI Study, Backed By Sam Altman https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a6MLQmY0h2s
[14] Universal Basic Income | Eolas Magazine https://www.eolasmagazine.ie/universal-basic-income/
[15] 2024 or 2025 which year do you think ubi gets implemented ... - Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/BasicIncome/comments/16b5pu9/2024_or_2025_which_year_do_you_think_ubi_gets/
[16] New findings from Sam Altman's basic-income study challenge one ... https://www.businessinsider.com/sam-altman-basic-income-study-new-findings-work-ubi-2024-12
[17] Get £1600 a month to do 'nothing' – welcome to an AI future where ... https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/ai-summit-paris-income-sam-altman-b2695965.html
[18] An experiment to inform universal basic income | McKinsey https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/social-sector/our-insights/an-experiment-to-inform-universal-basic-income
[19] The Report Card on Guaranteed Income Is Still Incomplete https://www.nytimes.com/2024/08/30/business/economy/the-report-card-on-guaranteed-income-is-still-incomplete.html
[20] The first results from the world's biggest basic income experiment - Vox https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2023/12/1/23981194/givedirectly-basic-income-experiment-abhijit-banerjee-tavneet-suri
[21] Sam Altman-Backed Group Completes Largest US Study on Basic ... https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-07-22/ubi-study-backed-by-openai-s-sam-altman-bolsters-support-for-basic-income
[22] Sam Altman's basic-income study is out. Here's what it found. - Reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/BasicIncome/comments/1e9f4hs/sam_altmans_basicincome_study_is_out_heres_what/
[23] How a Sam Altman-backed study into guaranteed income ... - Fortune https://fortune.com/2024/09/04/sam-altman-backed-study-guaranteed-income-widely-misinterpreted-ubi-personal-finance/
[24] Ireland Asks: What if Artists Could Ditch Their Day Jobs? https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/23/arts/ireland-basic-income-artists.html
[25] Full article: Cultural, creative and collective recovery: exploring a ... https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17510694.2023.2301120
[26] Basic Income for the Arts in Ireland - YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=72zWG29e8D4
[27] Reinhard Huss - Basic Income for the Arts in Ireland - LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/posts/reinhard-huss-2409b13a_basic-income-for-the-arts-in-ireland-what-activity-7264749473170341888-Vuag
[28] UBI Lab Arts - Facebook https://www.facebook.com/UBILabArts/
[29] From Universal Basic Income to Guaranteed Basic Income https://metropolitics.org/From-Universal-Basic-Income-to-Guaranteed-Basic-Income-An-Experiment-for-Cities.html
[30] BIEN — Basic Income Earth Network | Educating about Basic Income https://basicincome.org
[31] New from 'UN Chronicle: GenAI, critical minerals, UBI and more' https://www.un.org/en/delegate/new-un-chronicle-genai-critical-minerals-ubi-and-more
[32] Basic income as a policy option - OECD https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/basic-income-as-a-policy-option_77d7fe00-en.html
[33] An experiment to inform universal basic income | McKinsey https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/social-sector/our-insights/an-experiment-to-inform-universal-basic-income
[34] Temporary Basic Income to protect the world's poorest people could ... https://www.undp.org/press-releases/temporary-basic-income-protect-worlds-poorest-people-could-slow-surge-covid-19-cases-says-undp
[35] The Report Card on Guaranteed Income Is Still Incomplete https://www.nytimes.com/2024/08/30/business/economy/the-report-card-on-guaranteed-income-is-still-incomplete.html
[36] Is It Time for a Universal Basic Income (UBI)? - LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/time-universal-basic-income-ubi-ray-williams-qrccc
